Every superpower comes with fine print. Flight and invisibility are easy; powers with embarrassing conditions, hidden catches, and unexpected consequences are where the real debates begin. The closest vote splits belong to the people who read every last word before choosing.
Be able to play one niche instrument incredibly well and become famous for it, but not know how to play anything else: Be able to play any instrument in the world immediately after picking it up, but be unable to play any better than an average high-school player of that instrument:
Would you rather…
Sep 1, 2026
or
Be the best at something important but only half the time, e.g. you’re the best surgeon half the time, but the other half you’re a noob: Be consistently above average at something important:
Would you rather…
Aug 30, 2026
or
Have a personal theme song that plays whenever you enter a room: Have a dramatic slow motion effect whenever you walk:
Would you rather…
Aug 27, 2026
or
Know everyone’s darkest secret, but they also know yours: Have very thought you think said out loud:
Would you rather…
Aug 17, 2026
or
Read the mind of anyone thinking negatively about you: Read the mind of anyone thinking positively about you:
Would you rather…
Aug 15, 2026
or
Have healing powers, but you’re unable to use them on yourself: Having healing powers, but you’re only able to use them on yourself:
Would you rather…
Aug 14, 2026
or
Lose every argument, even though you’re always right: Win every argument, even though you’re always wrong:
Would you rather…
Aug 13, 2026
or
Know when everyone but you will die: Know when you will die but no one else:
Would you rather…
Aug 10, 2026
or
Be able to turn into any animal in the world: Be able to talk to any animal in the world:
Would you rather…
Aug 9, 2026
or
Be a normal person in the present: Be royalty 2,500 years ago: