Would you rather…

#181 · Sep 1, 2026
Be the best at something important but only half the time, e.g. you’re the best surgeon half the time, but the other half you’re a noob: Be consistently above average at something important:

Hot takes

reyna Be consistently above average at something important Sep 29, 2026

if you're above average at something important then you're basically the best at stuff, you could solve the one of the 7 unresolved problems, sure it might have some errors, but the solution would still be decent!!

Noah Be the best at something important but only half the time, … Sep 29, 2026

I could be the best gambler and win a ton of money then just leave when i become noob

'rav Be consistently above average at something important Sep 30, 2026

Consistency is obv the answer here because if you're an above average neurosurgeon, you're getting some serious money. Also, you would be insane at life. Image being smart, funny, athletic, and social able all at the same time and being good at all of them.

Your take

Please cast your vote before providing a take.

More superpowers & fantasy

Would you rather…

#3 · Mar 7, 2026
Always know when someone is lying to you: Always get away with lying yourself:

Would you rather…

#33 · Apr 6, 2026
Talk to animals: Understand every human language in the world:

Would you rather…

#2 · Mar 6, 2026
Live one 1,000-year life: Live ten different 100-year lives:

Would you rather…

#164 · Aug 15, 2026
Have healing powers, but you’re unable to use them on yourself: Having healing powers, but you’re only able to use them on yourself: